A study of 7,424 privately insured colon cancer patients found that a managed care presence in the market, as well as hospital competition, increased the likelihood that laparoscopic surgery would be used to treat colon cancer and at lower costs. The national team of researchers was led by a professor at the George Washington University School of Public Health and Health Services and reported in the journal Cancer.
Colon cancer is the second leading cause of cancer death in the U.S., and surgical resection is the standard of care. In 2004, there were approximately 134,000 colectomies performed in the U.S. The researchers examined whether market forces such as managed care or hospital competition affected the likelihood of an open resection, involving a long incision and lengthy hospitalization and recovery, versus laparoscopic surgery with minimal incisions and shorter hospital stays and recoveries. "This is a timely analysis in the era of healthcare reform," said Avi Dor, PhD, lead author and professor of health policy in the Department of Health Policy at GWU's school of public health. "It demonstrates that competition among providers can be harnessed to benefit patients and consumers."
A 10 percent increase of health maintenance organization (HMO) penetration in a market was associated with a 10.3 percent increase in the utilization of laparoscopy, the researchers found. Also, using a standard measure of hospital competition, they found that less competition was associated with a lower likelihood of laparoscopy. The team of researchers utilized a database of claims for privately insured individuals, allowing them to analyze actual payments. In fact, they found the average cost for laparoscopy was $18,133 compared to an average cost of $21,257 for open surgery.
In reviewing the data for the 7,424 patients treated between 2002 and 2007, the researchers adjusted for patient severity and risk. Of the 7,424 patients, 13.96 percent underwent laparoscopic surgery. Other findings included that by 2007, patients were 12.5 times more likely to undergo laparoscopy compared to 2002. Additionally, the price of colectomy procedures was 17.5 percent lower in 2007 than in 2002.